Turn-key 4-unit investment property on 2.56 acres in the heart of Finger Lakes wine country. Two detached buildings house four 1-bedroom, 1-bath apartments — two larger lofted units (built 2022) and two additional units (built 2023). Every unit features its own eat-in kitchen, living room, in-unit washer/dryer, porch, and a full appliance package, including dishwasher and microwave. Modern construction throughout with mini-split heating and cooling, metal roofs, vinyl siding, and slab foundations with 4 separate electric meters. The property includes a private stocked pond, wooded acreage, and stone driveway with ample parking. Located minutes from Seneca Lake, the Seneca Lake Wine Trail, Watkins Glen State Park, and Finger Lakes National Forest — ideal for an investor seeking strong cash flow or an owner looking to convert units to premium short-term rentals in one of New York's top tourism destinations. Tax assessment reflects the pre-subdivision parcel.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jason Scarbrough, Warren Real Estate
$535,000 (USD)
Hector Area Single Family Home
Pending
4482 Satterly Hill Road Hector, NY 14818
3 Bed
2.1 Baths
3384 sqft
MLS# R1673020
Set on 3 acres in the hills of Hector, this 3,100 sq ft contemporary offers sweeping valley and ridge views and a full-length barrel-vaulted glass conservatory with soaring wood-framed arches, knotty pine walls, and tile floors that stretch the width of the main level and overlook the pool. The great room connects directly to it: cathedral ceilings with natural-log beams, knotty-pine wainscoting, and a corner gas fireplace. The kitchen is a serious cook's space, with a commercial gas range, stainless steel appliances, generous cabinetry, and an island that opens seamlessly into the conservatory and out to the pool deck and built-in outdoor kitchen. Indoor-outdoor living isn't a feature here; it's the architecture. A heated 18x36 in-ground pool, concrete patio, large deck, and a built-in outdoor kitchen with gas grill and stone base. Detached 2-car garage with workshop space and unfinished upper level. The primary suite features a knotty pine cathedral ceiling with skylights, private deck access, and sweeping sunset views over the valley and the Seneca Lake ridge. Bedrooms two and three offer hardwood floors and shiplap accent walls. Laundry room with built-in cabinetry. Radiant floor heating throughout. Minutes to Seneca Lake, public hiking trails, Watkins Glen State Park, and Finger Lakes wine country.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jason Scarbrough, Warren Real Estate
$399,000 (USD)
Orange Area Land
Pending
3041 County Road 21 Orange, NY 14891
5 Bed
1 Baths
1883 sqft
MLS# R1685794
84 acres bordering Sugar Hill State Forest on all four corners — a rare offering in the Finger Lakes uplands where the land itself tells the story. A Conservation Easement held by the Finger Lakes Land Trust on 82 of the 84 acres, preserving the land's natural character in perpetuity. The remaining 2.228 acres adjacent to County Road 21 are unrestricted and include the residence.
The infrastructure here needs work, but it is substantial for a rural property of this scale. Solar panels installed in 2014 are owned outright and convey with the sale. Geothermal is in place, providing low-cost, high-efficiency climate control independent of utility fluctuations. A self-contained off-grid cabin built in 2021 rounds out the improvements — ideal as a guest retreat, hunting camp, or caretaker quarters.
The easement land is adjacent to thousands of acres of public forest, making this a compelling opportunity for conservation-minded buyers, hunters, hikers, or anyone seeking a private foothold in one of the most scenic and ecologically intact corridors in the Southern Finger Lakes. Sugar Hill State Forest is known for its trail network, wildlife habitat, and year-round recreation.
This is an estate sale. To be sold in its 'as-is' condition. Shown by appointment.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jason Scarbrough, Warren Real Estate
$108,000 (USD)
Montour Area Land
Pending
370 S Genesee Street Montour, NY 14865
Bed
0 Baths
sqft
MLS# R1680731
5 wooded acres in the Village of Montour Falls and direct access to the Catharine Valley Trail. Currently improved with a 130 sq ft solar-powered Tiny House on Wheels. Formerly operated as the Tiny House Seneca Lake Airbnb (114 reviews, 4.68 stars, 2018–2022). City water on site, composting toilet, outdoor shower. THOW, kayaks, bikes, and furnishings convey with the sale. Whether you want a weekend retreat, a continuation of the glamping business, or raw recreational acreage in the heart of the Finger Lakes, this property delivers rare flexibility at a village address.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jason Scarbrough, Warren Real Estate
$49,000 (USD)
Montour Area Multi-Family Home
Active
112 Walker Street Montour, NY 14865
4 Bed
2 Baths
2872 sqft
MLS# R1686795
Investor and contractor opportunity in the Village of Montour Falls. This 1848-built two-family home sits on a 0.36-acre village lot with municipal water, sewer, gas, and electric already in place. The structure requires complete renovation or removal. Whether you rehab, reconfigure into a single-family home, or clear the site and build new, the infrastructure and lot size make this a viable project. Estate sale, sold strictly as-is. Seller makes no representations regarding condition.
Listing by: NYS ALLIANCE / Listed By: Jason Scarbrough, Warren Real Estate